Davyvfr
I plan to purchase AnyRail very soon. But before I purchase it, I wanted to test it out with an overpass when designing the Tehachapi Loop in N-Scale. I was told by a friend on another forum that to calculate the degree of the track, simply multiply the diameter times Pi. Then divide it by 3, since that is the maximum angle of rise/climb. The problem I face is that I need to make sure that the track increases its height by exactly 3 degrees (I will be using Woodland Scenics Risers) and descends at 3 degrees. I need to have enough clearance for a tunnel and an N-Scale train to go through. Since this is the demo, I have not completed the layout of my full design. This is only the loop portion which will be the hardest part of the layout. Everything else is straight forward. If I can successfully design this loop with the correct heights, I will buy this product. (I am very impressed with the demo and all the features.)
Regards,
Davyvfr
(I attached the .any file)
David
As you can see from the percentages displayed, the current percentage is 3%. There's a little twist though, which is that this is the percentage in a straight line from endpoint to endpoint.
The reason for this is that usually you'll want to keep the percentage below say 3% on straight track, and even lower on curves as the friction will be higher. The tighter the curve, the higher the friction.
So in this case, if want exactly 3% on the centerline of the curve, you'll need to do some math indeed.
I assume the straights on the overpass are put in a flat position. Then the length of the rise is:
2 x pi x radius x (curve degrees / 360) =
2 x pi x 10 x 335/360 = 58.47". A rise of 3% means that you go up 0.03 x 58.47" = 1.754".
Quite close to what you have now!
What I've done to your loop is the following:
- Unglue everything
- Individually setting the heights of the flat straights to 0 and 1.754"
- Select the loop (click the first curve, then Shift-click the last curve)
- Click 'Smooth slope' on the Ribbon.
- Reglue everything
David.
Davyvfr
Thank you David for the reply. I tried your method and it seemed to work perfectly. I will be buying AnyRail very soon. The smooth slope feature works great and sure does exactly as its supposed to. I've attached the .any file if you want to double-check it but it seems to be perfect when fixing the height to 1.75 in. Am I taking a risk by doing the tight loop? I really haven't used my N-Scale Train for a long time so I don't really know what it is capable of. Is 1.75 enough room for an N-Scale train to pass with a tunnel underneath. The top portion of the overpass will be flat and go directly over the tunnel and so will the bottom portion of the straight track.
Davyvfr
Here is the .any file.
Regards,
David Becker
Thank you so much for your help, and again, I will definitely buy your product. :)
peartree
Dave,
I'll field this one, as David doesn't model in N scale (as far as I know). 1.75 inches isn't really a good separation. Unless you plan to model some time period from the 50's on back, it's not going to give you the clearance you need. That's especially true if you model from the 90's onward, since you'll be dealing with double-deck passenger cars and double-stack container cars. It's better to build it with about a 2" clearance between the top of the rail below and the bottom of the track support above. By the way, the prototype Tehachapi Loop uses a 2.5 percent grade, so your 3% isn't far off.
Now, as far as the posted plan goes, I don't think you're going to like the result, if you build off of it. 9 3/4" radius is about the minimum you can use in N scale and anything bigger than a SMALL switcher, steam or diesel, will go around it reliably, and you won't find many modern freight cars that look good doing it. You can forget passenger cars. Any passenger cars will go around that curve, but all of them will look cruddy doing so.
I hope this proves useful to you...
David
For European modelling, the NEM charts say you need a clearance of 33 millimeter from the top of the track for N scale.
That converts to 1.3".
So theoretically you might be just fine, but I agree with Jeff, you probably are better off with a loop having a greater diameter.
David.
Davyvfr
Thanks for the reply's. I will use a wider radius track and change the overpass to 2". I would like to go to 2.5 degrees but I can't seem to find risers that increase/decrease at 2.5 degrees. I do know that Woodland Scenics risers increase at 3 degrees. If I went 2.5 degrees, then something custom would have to be built.
Davyvfr
Ok, I've fixed the diameter and made it bigger by about 6.5 inches. Which should help with the incline and I have also fixed the overpass, insuring that the top track is above the lower track by 2 inches. The loop changed slightly but is a close-enough mock-up of the Tehachapi Loop. I think I'm getting mixed up here though, I remember you saying from a previous post that 3 degrees is from endpoint to endpoint in a straight line. I'm thinking of the 3 degrees from the track view. Sorry if I make it seem confusing, I'm a newbie to model railroading.
Regards,
Davyvfr
This is the new .any file.
peartree
Is there some particular reason you're not designing the Loop with flex track? Using the "Curve flex..." tool, you could specify the particular radius you want and you could use 3 90 degree curves plus one that would leave your track crossing at the specific angle you want.
Davyvfr
Jeff,
Thanks for the fast reply. Well, to tell you the truth I have not tried the flex track but its probably worth a try. I can go with any type of N-Scale track, just as long as it looks like a loop and has room for an overpass then I'm a happy camper. :) I will try the flex-track.
Regards,
Davyvfr
Davyvfr
What should I set the radius to? If the angle is set at 90 degrees, then should the radius be set at 15? I am trying to get the overpass to cross over at a straight since its easier to build a tunnel that way.
peartree
The way to do it is to create 3 90-degree pieces of flex track, then one more that is less than 90 degrees, allowing you to define exactly where you want the loop to cross itself. I'll create an example and have it to you in less than 12 hours. It's time to head for bed, now :)
peartree
Ok, here's a good example for you...
Davyvfr
Jeff,
Thank you for the example. I will look at it later today.
Regards,
Davyvfr
Davyvfr
Thank you Jeff and David for the reply's and the time spent when answering all my questions. The example loop fits perfectly and I will be sure to use it during my layout.
peartree
You're welcome. If there's any other help anyone can give, let us all know.