Steve Raiford
I'm new to AR and for the most part I am pleased with the product, especially the relatively easy learning curve. I just returned home from the NMRA national convention in Milwaukee, and on several occasions when I told someone I was working on my new layout design with AR the response I got was something like this: ".... I tried AR awhile ago but I found the track profiles to be so inaccurate that the end result wasn't useful or buildable...."
So far I haven't seen this, but of course I haven't started to build what I have designed. If I heard this only once, I wouldn't be nervous, but I heard it at least four times, and talked to no one that was still using the software. Can some of you "old time users" please enlighten me as to why I kept hearing this?
Thanks
Steve Raiford
Andy
Hi Steve,
In the early days when AR was DRail, glad the name was changed!!, it was very basic but easy to use ( and still is easy to use). It was/is totally different to any other program that I have tried, and comes from a different view of trying to get the track dimensions accurate for the scale you will be modeling and how much track your layout will need.
Regardless of what ever program you use, NONE will be accurate to the point where you can say this is how it will be exactly. There are still variables...like have you put in the correct dimensions your room, did you move your layout by 5 mm and forget to return back. When I started building my layout and laying down track I found some challenges not from the AR design but from my own mistakes in taking measurements. My layout has changed over the past 12 months and I'm still not happy with some areas, but that's my decision.
I posted a comment of MR when they compared programs and I don't think they really looked at it. I'm sorry to say if it's not American then they are not interested. That is a shame.
This forum is a fantastic way of having any of your questions answered don't be intimidated just ask. We are all modelers and we have a great program designer in David who gives great advise and takes on board improvements that people suggest.
Also I've lost count of the number of FREE updates I have received since I first purchased DR/AR in 2008. I think it's about 20.
Yours,
Andrew
David
There have been some misunderstandings about what AnyRail shows. The double lines are the rails, without the track bedding.
Especially for some Lionel Fastrack users this was an issue. Parallel track was planned with way too little room between the track, causing problems when actually putting it down for real. Especially for first time users, it's not always clear that most track systems have a certain geometry. For Lionel Fastrack for instance, the parallel track distance is 6". If you don't know that, and don't see the bedding, it's easy to make mistakes.
Since a few months, you can make AnyRail show the track bedding. This should help. Following the geometry as advised by the manufacturer is still your own responsibility though. We are planning to add some help to highlight problem areas where trains might hit each other due to lack of clearance.
For the rest, don't worry! We're actively developing the software, and we've plenty of customers and users worldwide. Of course, as we are continuously developing the product, there is a risk of information getting outdated. So please try it out for yourself. If you have a problem with some feature or missing functionality, please let us know so we can improve the product even further.
David.
Steve Raiford
Thanks for the feedback.
If the roadbed display is a relatively new feature, I can see how earlier users would have had difficulties. I wouldn't consider displaying trackage without roadbed. As I move down, or is it up, the learning curve I will probably develop a list of suggestions.
Steve Raiford
Chris
Hi Steve.
I, too, date back to early 2008. When I bought DRail I requested that Marklin Z scale be added and, lo and behold, it was about 2 weeks later. I then went about putting my layout into DRail and, satisfied with the result, started building it only to find that the point motors and other bits that stuck out from the track bed got in each others' way and even could overlap an adjacent track. Juts a few days later, at my request, these protuberances were added.
Over the last 2.5 years I have made numerous suggestions (as have others) most of which have been taken on board. These changes weren't done because of force of numbers, they were responses to request from a single individual. What other software company can boast that responsiveness to a single request?
I have tried some 7 or 8 different track planning programmes. Every one either locked up, crashed of was so complex to use that I gave up. What a pleasure it was to find DRail (by recommendation) and now AnyRail. I'll never go back to any of the others.
All the best,
Chris.
peartree
I read the same review article as Andrew did, but fortunately, it was well after I started using the software. I felt that the reviewer relegated it to some sort of 'B' list in his head and that was the end of it. Of course it's improved greatly since I started using it about 2 years ago. That's one of the things I love about it. It never stands still, so any review is a moving target. Still, I hope that some day MR magazine will do another set of reviews and give AR a fair shot at top place.
I think that part of it is that it's design aims aren't the same as those model railroad CAD programs. AR is the modern replacement for a pencil, a pad, and a large box of erasers. Who would want to use those when they had AR? Actually, I think that one should do all the design hard work with AR, then maybe use one of the CAD programs as a 'beautifier' for the end layout. I guess that could be looked at as one "lack" of AR, but I don't miss it at all. Lose the scenery and trees, but leave me the ease of use and speed of track editing! I can always do artwork on the printed result, but nothing can replace the ease of producing a great layout.